SCTSPRINT3

Sheriff Appeal Court Judgments - Civil

Opinions before 22 August 2017 can be found here
 

Where it is appropriate or desirable to do so, the Court provides an opinion setting out the reasons for its decision. Some decisions are given verbally by the Court at the conclusion of the hearing.

Written opinions will usually be provided when a case involves a matter of principle and/or a particular point of general public importance.

When issuing a written opinion, the Court should consider whether the opinion merits publication. The Court may rule that in the interests of justice, a particular case should not be published.

 

 

Search Judgments

Keyword Search

Help with keyword search

Advanced search

Use the advanced search to search for case information, publication or determination date

Advanced Search

List Judgments
Case Title Date of Determination Date Published Judge
PARKS OF HAMILTON (TOWNHEAD GARAGE) LIMITED AGAINST ELIZABETH DEAS 13/04/2022 21/06/2022
  • Sheriff Principal Aisha Y Anwar
DAVID MOTHERWELL AGAINST COVEA INSURANCE PLC
 29/04/2022 17/05/2022
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
  • Appeal Sheriff A M Cubie
  • Appeal Sheriff R D M Fife
JULIE SMITH AGAINST GORDON DUNCAN  02/05/2022 11/05/2022
  • Sheriff Principal D C W Pyle
HAESEL McDONALD AGAINST INDIGO SUN RETAIL LTD 21/04/2022 05/05/2022
  • Sheriff Principal M M Stephen QC
  • Sheriff Principal M W Lewis
  • Appeal Sheriff R D M Fife
CB AGAINST PRINCIPAL REPORTER 28/03/2022 01/04/2022
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
  • Appeal Sheriff R D M Fife
  • Appeal Sheriff T McCartney
APPEAL BY FRANK A SMART & SON LIMITED AGAINST ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL 28/03/2022 30/03/2022
  • Sheriff Principal Murray
  • Sheriff Principal Turnbull
  • Appeal Sheriff Ross
APPEAL BY PHYLLIS CARROLL OR COCKBURN OR McLEISH AGAINST ALAN CARSON McLEISH 09/03/2022 16/03/2022
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
  • Appeal Sheriff W H Holligan
  • Appeal Sheriff T McCartney
APPEAL BY MONEYBARN NO. 1 LTD AGAINST MISS ABBEIGH HARRIS 14/02/2022 11/03/2022
  • Appeal Sheriff W Holligan
  • Sheriff Principal M Stephen QC
  • Sheriff Principal M W Lewis
APPEAL BY CHAZA AFANDI AGAINST THE CITY OF EDINBURGH COUNCIL 04/03/2022 09/03/2022
  • Sheriff Principal M M Stephen QC
APPEAL BY IAN DAVID MACALLAN & RUTH NINA MACALLAN AGAINST IAN ARBUCKLE AND OTHERS 21/12/2021 16/02/2022
  • Sheriff Principal M W Lewis
  • Sheriff F Tait
  • Sheriff T McCartney
BILLY MCGOWAN AGAINST AYRSHIRE AND ARRAN HEALTH BOARD 24/05/2021 10/02/2022
  • Sheriff Principal A Y Anwar
APPEAL IN THE CAUSE COULTERS PROPERTY LIMITED AGAINST MARK ELLISON COULTER 04/02/2022 10/02/2022
  • Sheriff Principal D C W Pyle
  • Sheriff Principal M W Lewis
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
FIONA SIMPSON AGAINST NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL 29/04/2021 08/02/2022
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
  • Appeal Sheriff S F Murphy QC
  • Appeal Sheriff R D M Fife
APPEALS BY AW AGAINST PRINCIPAL REPORTER 25/10/2021 07/02/2022
  • Sheriff Principal D C W Pyle
  • Appeal Sheriff Murphy QC
  • Appeal Sheriff Small
FRANK A SMART & SON LTD AGAINST ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL 14/01/2022 04/02/2022
  • Sheriff Principal Murray
  • Sheriff Principal Turnbull
  • Appeal Sheriff Ross
PHILLIP SAMSON AGAINST DC WATSON & SONS (FENTON BARNS) LIMITED and UK INSURANCE LIMITED 01/02/2022 04/02/2022
  • Sheriff Principal Lewis
  • Appeal Sheriff Cubie
  • Appeal Sheriff N McFadyen
LAURA TIERNEY AGAINST G F BISSET (INVERBERVIE) LIMITED 09/12/2021 28/01/2022
  • Sheriff Principal D C W Pyle
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
  • Appeal Sheriff W H Holligan
ALEXANDER MEIKLE MCCABE AND OTHERS AGAINST RHODERICK PATTERSON AND ANOTHER 29/06/2021 26/01/2022
  • Sheriff Principal Lewis
  • Appeal Sheriff A M Cubie
  • Appeal Sheriff W H Holligan
T.A MILLARD (SCOTLAND) LIMITED AGAINST TRUSTEES OF THE CARDRONA CHARITABLE TRUST AND THE HIGHLAND COUNCIL 24/01/2022 26/01/2022
  • Sheriff Principal M W Lewis
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
  • Appeal Sheriff N A Ross
RM AND SB AS JOINT GUARDIANS OF THE ADULT PKM AGAINST GREATER GLASGOW HEALTH BOARD
 09/11/2021 26/11/2021
  • Sheriff Principal Murray
  • Sheriff Principal D Pyle
  • Appeal Sheriff N McFadyen
APPEAL BY JOHN CAPE t/a BRIGGATE INVESTMENTS IN THE CAUSE INGRID ALEXANDRA GRAY and CATHERINE ALEXANDRA SWEATON OR DEENEY AGAINST JOHN CAPE t/a BRIGGATE INVESTMENTS 18/10/2021 28/10/2021
  • Sheriff Principal D L Murray
  • Appeal Sheriff A M Cubie
  • Appeal Sheriff T McCartney
APPEAL IN THE CAUSE MARY McMASTER AGAINST JOHN McMASTER 11/10/2021 12/10/2021
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
APPEAL BY PAUL DONNELLY AGAINST SOUTH LANARKSHIRE COUNCIL  07/09/2021 12/10/2021
  • Sheriff Principal A Y Anwar
APPEAL BY DAVID AND ANDREA BRYSON AGAINST PAUL AND EVONNE SALMOND 18/08/2021 03/09/2021
  • Sheriff Principal D L Murray
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
  • Appeal Sheriff W H Holligan
APPEAL BY AND AGAINST KWL 22/07/2021 03/09/2021
  • Sheriff Principal A Y Anwar
  • Appeal Sheriff A Cubie
  • Appeal Sheriff W H Holligan
APPEAL BY FERGUS MURPHY AGAINST (FIRST) OGILVIE CONSTRUCTION AND ANOTHER 02/07/2021 26/08/2021
  • Sheriff Principal M M Stephen QC
JK IN RESPECT OF THE APPLICATION BY ARGYLL AND BUTE COUNCIL
 24/06/2021 04/08/2021
  • Sheriff Principal M W Lewis
  • Appeal Sheriff A L MacFadyen
  • Appeal Sheriff N McFadyen
NICHOLAS DICKSON AGAINST DUMFRIES AND GALLOWAY NHS HEALTH BOARD
 27/07/2021 04/08/2021
  • Sheriff Principal A Anwar
  • Appeal Sheriff Holligan
  • Appeal Sheriff A M Cubie
MICHAEL DUTHIE WILSON IN THE CAUSE GRAEME W CHEYNE (BUILDERS) LIMITED AGAINST MICHAEL DUTHIE WILSON
 03/08/2021 04/08/2021
  • Sheriff Principal A Y Anwar
  • Appeal Sheriff W H Holligan
  • Appeal Sheriff L Drummond QC
GORDON WALLACE AGAINST (FIRST) DAVID ROACHE AND (SECOND) LIVERPOOL VICTORIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
 
 28/07/2021 02/08/2021
  • Sheriff Principal M M Stephen QC
  • Sheriff Principal D L Murray
  • Sheriff Principal D C W Pyle
APPEAL BY THE SCOTTISH LEGAL AID BOARD BY ORMISTONS LAW PRACTICE LIMITED 11/06/2021 08/07/2021
  • Sheriff Principal M M Stephen QC
  • Sheriff Principal D L Murray
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
APPEAL BY JK AGAINST ARGYLL AND BUTE COUNCIL 13/05/2020 08/07/2021
  • Sheriff Principal M W Lewis
  • Appeal Sheriff A L MacFadyen
  • Appeal Sheriff N McFadyen
APPEALS BY (FIRST) SUZANNE HENDERSON AND OTHERS AGAINST MAPFRE MIDDLESEA INSURANCE PLC 25/05/2021 30/06/2021
NOTE IN AN OPPOSED MOTION FOR ACCESS TO DIGITAL RECORDING OF EVIDENCE IN THE CAUSE BILLY McGOWAN AGAINST AYRSHIRE AND ARRAN HEALTH BOARD  04/03/2021 30/06/2021
DANIELLE WEDDLE AGAINST GLASGOW CITY COUNCIL

 07/06/2021 10/06/2021
  • Appeal Sheriff Murphy QC
  • Appeal Sheriff N McFadyen
  • Sheriff Principal M M Stephen QC
FBI AGAINST MH 11/05/2021 28/05/2021
  • Appeal Sheriff Tait
  • Appeal Sheriff T McCartney
  • Appeal Sheriff Holligan

JOHN THOMPSON AGAINST MARY HOPKINSON


 22/03/2021 23/04/2021
  • Sheriff Principal A Y Anwar
GALBRAITH TRAWLERS LIMITED AGAINST THE ADVOCATE GENERAL FOR SCOTLAND 15/04/2021 23/04/2021
  • Appeal Sheriff Tait
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
  • Sheriff Principal M M Stephen QC
NATHAN BLAIR AGAINST HEATHER BAIRD 08/03/2021 10/03/2021
  • Sheriff Principal D L Murray
HERIOT-WATT UNIVERSITY AGAINST CHRISTIAN SCHLAMP 22/02/2021 05/03/2021
  • Appeal Sheriff W Holligan
  • Sheriff H K Small
  • Sheriff Principal A Y Anwar

TURCAN CONNELL (TRUSTEES) LIMITED AND THOMAS AITKEN CLARK IN THE CAUSE WEST LOTHIAN COUNCIL AGAINST TURCAN CONNELL (TRUSTEES) LIMITED AND THOMAS AITKEN CLARK

 19/02/2021 26/02/2021
  • Sheriff R D M Fife
  • Sheriff Principal D C W Pyle
  • Sheriff Principal D L Murray
D. MCLAUGHLIN AND SONS LIMITED AGAINST LINTHOUSE HOUSING ASSOCIATION LIMITED 28/01/2021 11/02/2021
  • Appeal Sheriff Tait
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
  • Sheriff Principal MW Lewis
ARGYLL COMMUNITY HOUSING ASSOCIATION LIMITED AGAINST DALEY GEORGE AP 04/02/2021 10/02/2021
  • Appeal Sheriff T McCartney
  • Sheriff D C W Pyle
  • Sheriff Principal D L Murray
GRANTON CENTRAL DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED AGAINST LEN LOTHIAN LIMITED 26/01/2021 09/02/2021
  • Appeal Sheriff L Drummond QC
  • Appeal Sheriff N Ross
  • Sheriff Principal Lewis
ROBBIE GORDON MUNRO AGAINST RONALD NORTON 22/01/2021 09/02/2021
  • Appeal Sheriff T McCartney
  • Appeal Sheriff N A Ross
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
D McLAUGHLIN AND SONS LIMITED AGAINST LINTHOUSE HOUSING ASSOCIATION LIMITED 23/12/2020 27/01/2021
  • Appeal Sheriff Tait
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull
  • Sheriff Principal M W Lewis
MICHAEL GEMMELL AGAINST KSL HAIR LIMITED AND DR FRANCISCO MAURICIO BERRIOS MERINO AND DR VIKAS KUNNURE AND AXA INSURANCE UK PLC 18/12/2020 27/01/2021
  • Sheriff Principal Turnbull
  • Sheriff Principal Murray
  • Sheriff Principal M M Stephen QC

NOTE IN APPLICATION FOR PERMISSION TO APPEAL TO THE COURT OF SESSION IN TERMS OF SECTION 113 OF THE COURTS REFORM (SCOTLAND) ACT 2014 BY 1. GELL LEISURE LIMITED; 2. SARAH GELL; AND 3. DUNCAN GELL IN THE CAUSE GORDON MATTHEW COLQUHOUN AND IRENE DORIS COLQUHOUN AGAINST 1. GELL LEISURE LIMITED; 2. SARAH GELL; AND 3. DUNCAN GELL

 31/08/2020 22/01/2021
  • Sheriff Principal D L Murray

LM AGAINST DG’s EXECUTOR

 23/12/2020 21/01/2021
  • Sheriff Principal C D Turnbull

CABOT FINANCIAL UK LTD AGAINST CATHERINE WEIR

 13/01/2021 21/01/2021
  • Appeal Sheriff N Ross
  • Sheriff Principal A Y Anwar
  • Sheriff Principal M Lewis