SCTSPRINT3

Thursday 13th September 2018

 

Issue No. 261

 

C O N T E N T S

 

 

 

 

Notice

Unopposed Motions

Further Procedure Warning List

Further Procedure Warning List Personal Injury

Closed Record Warning List

Calling List

Single Bills & Inner House Motions

Starred and Unstarred Motions

Outer House Rolls

Inner House Rolls

 


N O T I C E

 

The Offices of Court and the Justiciary Office will be closed on Monday 17th September 2018.

 

Please find below details of intimation, opposition and enrolment dates to accommodate the public holidays

 

Intimation date

Opposition Date

Motion Lodged Date

12/09/18

14/09/18

18/09/18

13/09/18

18/09/18

19/09/18

14/09/18

19/09/18

20/09/18

18/09/18

20/09/18

21/09/18

19/09/18

21/09/18

24/09/18

 

Intimation, opposition and enrolment dates return to normal, thereafter.

 

 

Motions intimated by other means in accordance with Parts 3 and 4 of Chapter 23 of the Rules of the Court of Session 1994.

 

Motions for Tuesday 18th September must be enrolled no later than 4.00pm on Thursday 13th September and may be opposed until 12.30pm on Friday 14th September.

 

Motions for Wednesday 19th September must be enrolled no later than 4.00pm on Friday 14th September and may be opposed until 12.30pm on Tuesday 18th September.

 

 

Callings

 

Cases lodged for calling all day Thursday 13th September and up until 12.30pm on Friday 14th September will call on Tuesday 18th September.

 

Cases lodged for calling from 12.30pm until close of business Friday 14th September will call Wednesday 19th September.

 

 

___________________________

 


N O T I C E

 

 

At present, the Inner House does not charge parties the prescribed fee for the late cancellation of hearings before three or more judges, as provided for under Schedule 1 of the Court of Session etc. Fees Order 2018 (SSI 2018/83) paragraphs B20 and C16.

 

The Lord President has directed that the late cancellation fees set out in the Order should now be charged, in appropriate cases. 

 

This change will take effect from the opening of the new legal year commencing on Monday 24 September 2018.  However, the Lord President has directed that the fee should be charged only where a hearing is cancelled by parties within seven working days, not the 28 days provided for in the Order.  In cases where the court requires to cancel the hearing no fee will be payable.  In other cases, the fee may be waived, by application to the court, where it would be reasonable in all the circumstances so to do.

 

 

 

___________________________

 

 

 

 


 

UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

 

 

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on Wednesday 12th September

 

 

A164/18 Carol Craig v Lothian NHS Health Board

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

A165/18 Michelle Cull &c v Lanarkshire Health Board

 

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

A155/12 Real Estate Developments (Scotland) v Leslie Battersby &c

 

Paul Hannah Solicitors

 

A745/14 Scotland Gas Networks Plc v Skene Group Ltd

 

Addleshaw Goddard

 

PD71/15 Elizabeth Donohoe v Zimmer Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

 

A83/15 Graham Cowell-Smith v Sara Hornibrook &c

 

Shoosmiths LLP

 

 

A548/15 Edward Price v Zimmer Ltd &c

 

Pinsent Masons LLP

 

 

A436/17 Stewart & Shields Ltd v Douglas St Brides Community Group

 

TC Young LLP

 

A447/13 Taqa Bratani Ltd v Stewart Milne Group Ltd &c

 

Pinsent Masons LLP

 

 

A170/16 The Governer & Company of Bank of Scotland v Golds Solicitors &c

 

Brodies LLP

 

 

PD2465/14 Gillian Cowan v Transform Medical Group (CS) Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

 

PD2440/14 Rosalba Di Paolantonio v Transform Medical Group (CS) Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

 

PD1321/14 Daniel Ferguson v Luddon Construction Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

 

PD836/14 Heather Skene v Transform Medical Group (CS) Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

 

A308/17 Yvette McElwee &c v Neil Chalmers &c

 

MDDUS

 

A90/18 Roy Wilson v Fife Health Board

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

PD241/18 Agnes Caulfield &c v Upper Clyde Shipbuilders Ltd &c

 

Thompsons

 

 

PD219/18 Gladys Cousin &c v Galiford Try Infrastructure Ltd &c

 

Clyde & Co

 

PD121/18 Peter McGuigan v William Grant & Sons Distillers Ltd

 

Bonnar Accident Law

 

PD121/18 Peter McGuigan v William Grant & Sons Distillers Ltd

 

BTO Solicitors LLP

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

___________________________

 

 

 

 

 


FURTHER PROCEDURE WARNING LIST

 

 

Further procedure is required in the undernoted cases.   Accordingly the cases will be put out By Order in the near future.

 

 

1

A157/14 Elizabeth McAleese v Scottish Power Ltd

 

CMS

 

Brodies LLP

 

 

 

 

FURTHER PROCEDURE WARNING LIST

 

 

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

 

Further procedure is required in the undernoted cases.   Accordingly the cases will be put out By Order in the near future.

 

 

1

PD490/17 Kenneth Cruickshank v the Advocate General for Scotland

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

BLM

 

 

 

CLOSED RECORD WARNING LIST

 

 

Closed Records have not been lodged timeously in the undernoted cases.   Accordingly the causes will be put out By Order in the near future.

 

1

A547/15 Diane Catto v Biomet UK Ltd &c

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

Pinsent Masons LLP

 

2

A745/14 Scotland Gas Networks Plc v Skene Group Ltd

 

Addleshaw Goddard

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

___________________________


COURT OF SESSION

 

 

CALLING LIST

 

Thursday 13th September

 

 

1

PD292/18 Graham Finnie AG Hugh Wylie.

 

Bonnar Accident Law

 

2

PD145/18 Catherine Murphy AG Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Trust.

 

Allan McDougall

 

3

A333/17 SMW Limited AG GT TMGL Limited.

 

Shepherd & Wedderburn

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

___________________________

 

 

 

 


 

Friday 14th September

 

EXTRA DIVISION

 

INNER HOUSE UNSTARRED MOTION

 

CA87/17 The Coal Authority v Pegasus Fire Protection Co Ltd &c

 

MacRoberts LLP

 

 

 

 

 

LORD BRAILSFORD

 

STARRED MOTION

 

1 hour

F40/18 Kae Murray v David Murray

SKO Family Limited

Turcan Connell

 

 

 

 

LORD BOYD OF DUNCANSBY

 

PETITION DEPARTMENT

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

P492/18 Pet: Dunshou He for Judicial Review

 

Office of the Advocate General

 

 

 

P309/15 Pet: Muhammad Nazir for Judicial Review

 

MHD Law

 

 

 


Friday 14th September

 

TO BE ALLOCATED

 

STARRED MOTIONS

 

30 mins

PD249/18 Francis Richardson v Scottish Power UK Plc

 

Shepherd & Wedderburn

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

 

30 mins

PD2764/15 Seoras MacRitchie v Iain Morrison &c

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

Brodies LLP

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

___________________________

 

 

 

 

 


OUTER HOUSE ROLLS

 

 

LADY CLARK OF CALTON – L Davies, Clerk

 

Wednesday 19th September

 

Procedural Hearing

 

A775/15 Andrew Hankey v Lanarkshire Health Board

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

By Order (Adjustment)

 

A415/17 Dorothy Cochrane &c v Fife Health Board

 

Thorntons Law LLP

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

By Order

 

A178/10 Shaun Munro v Lanarkshire Health Board

 

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

 

Thursday 20th September

 

By Order

 

A294/17 Smrithi Pucadiyal v Kongsbery Maritime Ltd

 

Party

 

BTO Solicitors LLP

 

 

PD241/13 Martin Pettingell v Jordan Caird &c

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

BLM

 

 


LORD GLENNIE – L MacLachlan, Clerk

 

Friday 21st September

 

By Order
at 9.30am

 

AD6/17 Petition of West Lothian Council for Variation of a Permanence Order in a permanence order with authority to adopt re AM

 

 

 

 

 

 

LORD BRAILSFORD – L Davies, Clerk

 

Tuesday 18th September

 

Pre-Proof Hearing
at 9.30am

 

F59/17 Jane Hartnell-Beavis v Michael Blanchard

 

SKO Family Limited

 

Harper Macleod LLP

 

 

 

Wednesday 19th September

 

By Order
at 9.00am

 

F29/18 Allison Jeynes-Ellis v Guy Jeynes-Ellis

 

Turcan Connell

 

Brodies LLP

 

 

 

Pre-Proof Hearing
at 9.30am

 

F28/16 Arthur McGoff v Olga McGoff

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

 

F148/14 Olga McGoff (AP) v Arthur McGoff (AP)

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

Thorntons Law LLP

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

Thursday 20th September

 

Continued Motion
at 9.00am

 

A353/15 Katrina Nicoll &c v Grampian Health Board

 

Harper Macleod LLP

 

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

Hearing under Section 15K of the Debtors (Scotland) Act 1987
at 9.30am

 

F66/18 Anna Leckie v Peter Leckie

 

Turcan Connell

 

 

 

 

Friday 21st September

 

By Order
at 9.00am

 

A133/16 James Carr &c v R H Independent Healthcare Ltd

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

Bonnar Accident Law

 

Dentons UK

 

 

 

LORD BANNATYNE – C Stark, Clerk

 

Tuesday 18th September

 

Continued Proof
at 9.00am

 

A264/11 Paul Motion &c v Cheryl Binnie

 

BTO Solicitors LLP

 

Party

 

 

 


Wednesday 19th September

 

Procedural Hearing
between 9.00am and 9.30am

 

CA1/18 M G Construction Ltd v AGD Equipment Ltd

 

Brandon Malone & Company

 

Anderson Strathern LLP

 

 

 

Thursday 20th September

 

Preliminary Hearing
between 9.00am and 9.30am

 

CA84/18 Caudwell Properties (108) Ltd v AWG Group Ltd

 

Morisons LLP

 

 

Eversheds Sutherland (International) LLP

 

 

 

Friday 21st September

 

Motion Roll Hearing
between 9.00am and 9.30am

 

A454/16 Mallory Square v Caledonia Financial Planning

 

TC Young LLP

 

Brodies LLP

 

 

 

 

 

LORD TYRE – C Munn, Clerk

 

Wednesday 19th September

 

Procedural Hearing

 

A2/17 William Whyte v Lothian Health Board

 

Anderson Strathern LLP

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

 


By Order (Adjustment)

 

A466/14 Anthony Wilkinson &c v Lothian Health Board &c

 

Harper Macleod LLP

 

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

Cannons Law Practice

A611/14 Gregor Tait &c v Lanarkshire Health Board &c

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

MDDUS

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

By Order

 

A437/17 Marian McCrorey v Greater Glasgow Healthboard

 

 

Anderson Strathern LLP

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

 

Thursday 20th September

 

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

Case calling By Order in terms of Rule of Court 43.10(3)

 

PD2783/15 Sarah Ferguson &c v Shirley Denovan

 

Lindsays

 

 

Clyde & Co

 

 

PD101/16 Robin Cunningham &c v Total Reinstatement Services Ltd

 

Jackson Boyd LLP

Clyde & Co

 

 

 


LORD BOYD OF DUNCANSBY – C Grant, Clerk

 

Wednesday 19th September

 

By Order (Adjustment)

 

A193/17 Caroline Robertson &c v Highland Health Board &c

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

A269/17 Steven Kilpatrick v South Beach Medical Centre &c

 

Thompsons

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

MDDUS

 

Thursday 20th September

 

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

Cases calling By Order in terms of Rule of Court 43.6(3)

 

PD519/17 Jonathan Sim v Dolphin Drilling Personnel PTE &c

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

Keoghs Scotland LLP

 

 

PD61/18 Paul Richards v Lettuce Up North Ltd &c

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

Plexus Law

 

 

 

Friday 21st September

 

By Order

 

PD339/17 Robert Reid &c v Upper Clyde Shipbuilders Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

 

Clyde & Co

 

 

PD2659/15 Scott McEvoy &c v Sir Robert McAlpine Ltd &c

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

Clyde & Co

 

 


LADY WISE – T Kell, Clerk

 

Tuesday 18th September

 

Pre-Proof Hearing
at 9.30am

 

F82/17 Jane Ryder v Alasdair Ryder

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

Morton Fraser LLP

 

 

 

Wednesday 19th September

 

By Order
at 9.15am

 

F48/18 Raymond Kohli v Ramanjit Kohli

 

Morton Fraser LLP

 

Kennedy’s Scotland

 

By Order

 

A108/14 Pauline Burns v Fife Health Board

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

 

Thursday 20th September

 

By Order
at 9.30am

 

F83/17 Jennifer Gordon v Craig Gordon

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

SKO Family Limited

 

 

By Order

 

A550/13 Gwen Lawrence (AP) &c v Tayside Health Board

 

Lindsays

 

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

 


Friday 21st September

 

FAMILY ACTION

In terms of rule 49, a proof has been allowed in the following action

 

F52/18 Douglas Dick v Amy Vallance-Dick

 

Morton Fraser LLP

 

 

TC Young Solicitors

 

 

By Order
at 9.30am

 

F46/18 Gordon Grubb v Laura Donald

 

Thorntons Law LLP

 

Thorley Stephenson SSC

 

 

 

 

LORD ARMSTRONG – I Forbes, Clerk

 

Wednesday 19th September

 

By Order (Adjustment)
at 9.30am

 

A362/16 Emma Brown v Dumfries & Galloway Health Board &c

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

Procedural Hearing

 

A868/15 Andrew Stevenson &c v Lothian Health Board

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

By Order

 

PD249/18 Francis Richardson v Scottish Power UK Plc

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

 

Shepherd & Wedderburn

 

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

Thursday 20th September

 

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

Cases calling By Order in terms of Rule of Court 43.10(3)

 

PD525/17 Jim Canavan &c v Russell Laing

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

Plexus Law

 

 

 

By Order

 

P1218/16 Pet: Ruth Hogg &c for orders under section 996

 

Davidson Chalmers

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

 

Friday 21st September

 

By Order (Adjustment)

 

A688/14 Richard Syred v Lady Christine De La Rue

 

Thorntons Law LLP

 

Turcan Connell

 

 

By Order

 

PD10/18 Frances Lewis &c v Balfour Beatty Kilpatrick Ltd &c

 

Thompsons

 

CMS

 

 

 

 


LADY WOLFFE – E Hunter, Clerk

 

Wednesday 19th September

 

Starred Motion
between 9.00am and 9.30am

 

P646/18 Pet: Phonographic Performance Ltd breach of interdict (Orr)

 

Burness Paull LLP

 

 

 

Thursday 20th September

 

Procedural Hearing
between 9.30am and 10.00am

 

CA97/16 J H & W Lamont of Heathfield Farm &c v Chattisham Ltd

 

Dentons UK

 

 

Gilson Gray LLP

 

 

 

Friday 21st September

 

By Order
between 9.00am and 9.30am

 

CA45/17 Muhammad Iftikhar v CIP Property (AIPT) Ltd

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

Dentons UK

 

 

 

 

 

LORD ERICHT – L Morgan, Clerk

 

Wednesday 19th September

 

By Order
between 9.30am and 10.00am

 

CA46/18 Mitie Property Services (UK) Ltd v Kenny Robson &c

 

Burness Paull LLP

Russel + Aitken

 

 

 

Thursday 20th September

 

Starred Motion
at 9.30am

 

P277/17 Pet: Sky Plc &c for breach of interdict

 

Burness Paull LLP

 

 

 

Procedural Hearing
between 9.30am and 10.00am

 

CA44/16 Aggreko UK Ltd v Morgan Sindall Construction & Infrastructure Ltd &c

 

Shepherd & Wedderburn

 

 

Brodies LLP

 

 

 

 

Friday 21st September

 

Preliminary Hearing
between 9.30am and 10.00am

 

CA61/18 Paul McNiven &c v Grand Thistle Homes Ltd

 

Harper Macleod LLP

 

Gillespie Macandrew LLP

 

 

 

 

LADY CARMICHAEL – R Newlands, Clerk

 

Thursday 20th September

 

Procedural Hearing

 

P1136/17 Pet: Joseph Millbank (AP) for Judicial Review

Drummond Miller LLP

 

SGLD

 

 

P514/18 Pet: April Prior (AP) for Judicial Review

Drummond Miller LLP

 

SGLD

 

 

P511/18 Pet: Gordon Burns (AP) for Judicial Review

Drummond Miller LLP

 

SGLD

 

 

 


TO BE ALLOCATED

 

Tuesday 18th September

 

Proof (4 days)

 

A35/13 Kenneth Whitcombe v Bank of Scotland Plc

 

Party

 

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

 

 

 

TO BE ALLOCATED

 

Tuesday 18th September

 

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

 

Proof (4 days)

 

PD515/17 Roseanne Fisher v Daniel Smith &c

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

DWF LLP

 

 

 

 

TO BE ALLOCATED

 

Thursday 20th September

 

Substantive Hearing

 

P295/18 Pet: Amadou Sanghott for Judicial Review

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

Office of the Advocate General

 

 

 


TO BE ALLOCATED

 

Friday 21st September

 

Procedure Roll

 

A200/07 Brian Gracie v Edinburgh City Council

Party

 

City of Edinburgh Council

 

 

Procedural Hearing

 

P532/18 Nadir Mohammed for Judicial Review

Drummond Miller LLP

 

Office of the Advocate General

 

 

P517/18 Zana Othman for Judicial Review

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

Office of the Advocate General

 

 

Oral Hearing

 

P439/18 Pet: Harpeet Singh for Judicial Review

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

Office of the Advocate General

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

___________________________

 

 

 

 


INNER HOUSE ROLLS

 

 

FIRST DIVISION

 

Tuesday 18th September

 

Single Bill
at 10.00am

 

P321/15 RA McMaster &c v the Scottish Ministers

 

Davidson Chalmers

 

SGLD

 

 

 

 

EXTRA DIVISION

 

Wednesday 19th September

 

Single Bill
between 10.00am and 11.30am

 

XA51/18 Thomas Quail for leave to appeal a decision of the Scottish Legal Complaints Commission

 

Clyde & Co

 

 

 

 

Friday 21st September

 

Single Bill
between 10.00am and 1.00pm

 

XA46/18 William Shields for leave to appeal a decision of the Scottish Legal Complaints Commission

 

Party

 

Brodies

 

 

 

 

 

___________________________